REVIEW: “Star Trek: The Fall — A Ceremony of Losses”

Star Trek: The Fall
A Ceremony of Losses
By David Mack
Release Date: October 29, 2013
Pocket Books

 

From the back cover:

THE NEEDS OF THE MANY: Despite heroic efforts by Thirishar ch’Thane, the Andorian species is headed for extinction. Its slow march toward oblivion has reached a tipping point, one from which there will be no hope of return.

THE NEEDS OF THE FEW: With countless lives at stake, the leaders of Andor, the Federation, and the Typhon Pact all scheme to twist the crisis to their political gain—at any price.

THE NEEDS OF THE ONE: Unwilling to be a mere bystander to tragedy, Doctor Julian Bashir risks everything to find a cure for the Andorians. But his courage will come at a terrible cost: his career, his freedom . . . and maybe his life.

My thoughts:

After Una McCormack’s absolutely stellar The Crimson Shadow, how could another book in The Fall possibly measure up?

Quite well, as it turns out. I do not envy David Mack's task of having to follow Una McCormack's fantastic entry in The Fall, but unsurprisingly, he handles the task with his usual aplomb. A Ceremony of Losses continues the story of the Andorian reproductive crisis; a story-line that, surprisingly, has now been with us for over a decade. Against the backdrop of the recent tragic events that have befallen the Federation, Dr. Julian Bashir embarks on a personal mission of mercy to help solve the Andorians’ dilemma.

His plan is to access the Shedai meta-genome, an act which, if discovered, would led to the end of his Starfleet career at best -- and at worst, charges of treason and a life in prison. The meta-genome is the Federation’s most closely-guarded secret, possibly for good reason. Featured in the unparalleled book series Vanguard, the Shedai meta-genome was discovered by Starfleet a century earlier. Its discovery and the fallout from that event led to a short but brutal conflict with the Tholian Assembly.

vanguard'A Ceremony of Losses' reaches all the way back to the TOS-era 'Vanguard' series.

In addition, while the meta-genome could yield a plethora of benefits, the knowledge it contains could also be used in very destructive ways. In fact, Project Genesis was derived from information in the meta-genome, a device that could be used as a devastating weapon. Needless to say, Starfleet and the Federation will do everything it can to ensure that the information contained in the meta-genome stays under lock and key.

It is against all of this that Bashir must struggle to find a cure for the Andorian people. This herculean task is the ultimate embodiment of Bashir's frequent "uphill battles," famously enacted in the holosuites on DS9 through the Battle of the Alamo and the Battle of Thermopylae. Instead of a small force of Texans holding out against a vast Mexican army, or 7000 Spartans against a force of 100,000 Persians, Bashir and a few genetic scientists must go up against the entire might of Starfleet and the Federation, as well as a reactionary Andorian government that would rather consolidate its hold on power than allow their people to be cured.

A Ceremony of Losses touches on a lot of topics that are worth deep examination. The political party in power on Andor is very right-wing and reactionary, and their base is very much against science and anything that goes against their religious beliefs. Key to maintaining their power is getting their base riled up and ready to fight.

The "President Pro Tem" of the Federation, a Bajoran by the name of Ishan Anjar, is also extremely reactionary and a true "warhawk." Quick to anger and looking to score cheap politcal points at the expense of the prudent course of action, Ishan's (hopefully short) regime is a stark contrast to the presidency of Nanietta Bacco. It is in the middle of this charged political climate that Bashir finds himself.

As usual, David Mack handles the characters in his book as expertly as he does the grand, epic plots. In particular, the strained-of-late relationship between Bashir and Dax gets some very welcome development, and I'm eager to see where it goes in future novels. Also, this novel features the return for one of my favorite lit-only characters: Thirishar Ch'Thane, formerly the science officer of Deep Space 9.

chaneThe young Andorian returns to the 'Deep Space Nine' narrative.

A Ceremony of Losses, much like David R. George III's Revelation and Dust, leaves several plot points dangling at the end. A few of these are obviously specific to The Fall and will be picked up in the remaining two books in the series. However, Bashir's story in particular looks to be continued in David Mack's 2014 novel, Section 31: Disavowed, which is set to be released toward the end of next year.

In addition, due to the lack of mention of the plot points revealed at the end of Revelation and Dust in this novel, we can probably assume that those stories will be continued in another novel further along in the DS9 story, and will not feature in The Fall.

Final thoughts:

I was a little worried about being disappointed after the high level of quality of The Crimson Shadow, but my fears were completely unfounded. Truly, this is unsurprising, as I have yet to be disappointed by anything of David Mack's that I have read. He keeps his streak going with A Ceremony of Losses.

This epic and far-reaching entry in The Fall will be an influence on story-lines going forward for many novels to come. As usual, Mack remains secure in his position as one of my favorite Trek-lit authors of all time. Another winner!

- Reviewed by Literature Editor Dan Gunther

div_spacer

crimson_small Order Star Trek The Fall: A Ceremony of Losses 

  • James

    I feel terrible for just pointing this out.

    But why is the Defiant firing blue solid phasers from it’s pulse phaser ports?

    • http://www.treklit.com/ Dan Gunther

      No worries, us Trekkies are nothing if not detail-obsessed!

      Short answer: no idea. Artistic licence? We’ve seen the Defiant firing solid phasers before, but you’re right, not from the pulse phaser ports. And certainly never blue! But still, it is a beautiful cover.

  • Leola Broth

    Thank you! Good review. Did you ever interview the author for this one? I can’t find it if you did

    • http://www.treklit.com/ Dan Gunther

      Yep, we did an interview back in October before the book was released. You can find that interview here: http://trekcore.com/blog/2013/10/exclusive-david-mack-interview/

      • Leola Broth

        Thank you Dan. Love your reviews and interviews! Best Star Trek site around :)

        • http://www.treklit.com/ Dan Gunther

          Thanks for the kind words! Glad you’re enjoying them! :)

  • Sykes

    Another great read, this one. This one and Una’s book are the kind where I find myself being just a little sad that we can’t see this stuff on screen. (Not that a book is somehow a lesser thing!)

    Just picture Garak and Picard sharing the screen. Or the Aventine streaking into a fracas above Andoria.

    • mjdavid

      Other discussion threads on this very site have delved into “what if” Star Trek came back to TV. What would they do with it? I have thought since I started reading The Fall it would make a good TV miniseries, much like the Destiny series. Too bad it’s not that easy.

      • Guest

        t would be neat to see the novels brought to life via a fan-made all-CG
        animated show. That way you could select voice actors for quality
        without concern for appearance. It could then be released as a youtube
        series, breaking the massive amounts of story material into digestible
        tidbits. Start with the Destiny novels and you’ve got enough material
        for years of 30-minute or 1-hour episodes.

      • Sastrei

        It would be neat to see the novels brought to life via a fan-made all-CG
        animated show. That way you could select voice actors for quality
        without concern for appearance. It could then be released as a youtube
        series, breaking the massive amounts of story material into digestible
        tidbits. Start with the Destiny novels and you’ve got enough material
        for years of 30-minute or 1-hour episodes.

  • Stefan Garcia

    It would be neat to see the novels brought to life via a fan-made all-CG animated show. That way you could select voice actors for quality without concern for appearance. It could then be released as a youtube series, breaking the massive amounts of story material into digestible tidbits. Start with the Destiny novels and you’ve got enough material for years of 30-minute or 1-hour episodes.

  • SFSeries&Movies

    More than halfway through this one, was a slow starter but really enjoying it till now, one of my favs Trek books