Our popular Next Generation workprint series continues today with an exclusive first look at “Evolution“, the third season premiere! This twenty-three-year-old VHS tape is dated August 10, 1989, and like the other VHS recordings in this series, it features an early, unfinished copy of the episode, with missing visual effects, music, and voice-over audio.

The original VHS tapes, generously shared with TrekCore by Cyril “Patchou” Paciullo


Workprint vs. Finished Episode

In addition to several scenes featuring slightly different camera angles, this “Director’s Cut” also includes over seven minutes of additional scenes cut from the broadcast version of the episode! We’ve been provided a copy of the original VHS transfer, and we’re happy to present the first of two exclusive cut-down packages highlighting the most prominent deleted scenes – in proper context with the finished episode – along with a scene-by-scene breakdown!



Our take: This short sequence, removed from the episode’s opening scene, is the first of several cuts all pertaining to Wesley Crusher’s storyline. It’s the first of many scenes highlighting Wesley’s devotion to his studies and to his Acting Ensign duties.

The final episode only references his reading of an “unauthorized biography” of Dr. Stubbs – rather than everything written by (or about) the man.


Our take: This scene is the first major cut from the episode, and it’s one that we would have loved to see remain in the final version of the story. Guest stars Scott Grimes (as Eric, in blue) and Amy O’Neill (as Annette, in yellow) – and a girl in magenta, credited only as “Eric’s Girlfriend” in the script – are the first group of real teenagers we’ve seen on board the Enterprise-D.

Up until this point in the series, the only other kids we’ve seen on the ship are much younger than Wesley – he was the “grown up” of the abducted group in Season 1’s “When The Bough Breaks” – and it’s nice to see that the Acting Ensign really does have a group of age-appropriate peers in his life… even though he’s blowing them off to hang out with the adults.

Scott Grimes (who will be seen years later on HBO’s Band of Brothers, NBC’s E.R., and FOX’s American Dad!) does the best he can with the dialogue he’s given, but Amy O’Neill gives a fairly terrible performance – the script indicates that Annette is “clearly interested in Wes”, but O’Neill gives about the blandest possible reading of her single line.

How about those funky ski suits, though? That’s the kind of Trek costuming we like to see, even on a fuzzy VHS recording.


Our take: These few slices from Stubbs’ first visit to sickbay are the first of several cuts dealing with his views towards women, and their removal was a good decision. Dialogue filmed but cut from the conference lounge scene which follows offers this insight into Stubbs’ exploits:

…he doesn’t like women very much.

Odd. The research material on Doctor Stubbs
includes not a few references from gossip
columns. It suggests females
find him quite attractive.

Not this one.


Our take: The return of Eric and Annette! This is the second big scene featuring these kids – complaining about Wesley to his mom – and this time Mary McCusker joins in as an unnamed sickbay duty nurse.

Her role in the final episode is reduced to helping Stubbs sit up in the first sickbay scene, but here she gets several lines of dialogue (including the cringe-worthy “You look like you could use something warm inside you!”), and even gets to act out an electrocution-by-replicator attack by the nanites.

Aside from saving us from another awful performance by Amy O’Neill (not helped by that unflattering camera angle looking up her nose), the removal of this scene changes the nanites’ storyline, as well – in the final version of the episode, the only person hurt by the nanites’ actions is Stubbs, in a seeming deliberate attack of retribution.

Not counting the steller phenomena outside the ship, no one on board is seriously put in danger – but this scene, featuring violent holodeck malfunctions and random lightning attacks by replicators, makes the ship’s “control problems” seem much more dangerous to the crew.

With this cut, all of O’Neill and Grimes’ lines are now removed from the final episode. The only time we see the teens is in the closing scene in Ten Forward, where Crusher watches Wesley and his friends from across the room… and doesn’t seem to know anything about Annette, who walks in with Wesley’s arm around her shoulder.


Our take: Finally, somebody stops to ask if the malfunctions could be some sort of attack on the Enterprise! Worf gets to act suspicious, Troi senses nothing (not surprising, since the “enemy” is machine-based), and Wesley gets to look guilty while listening in on the conversation.

Did this need to stay in the in the episode? Not really. Riker’s reaction is basically, “Well, maybe?”, and Picard doesn’t even ask Worf to look into the possibility of an outside influence on the ship.


Our take: This little trim from Geordi’s repair work was probably removed to get rid of Wesley’s goofy line – “Nice going, Geordi!”

He’s the Chief Engineer, kid – he doesn’t need you to cheer him on.

There’s more! Part 2 of “Evolution” Deleted Scenes


We’re eager to hear your feedback, so tell us your thoughts about these new scenes in the comments below!

Order Star Trek: The Next Generation Season 4 Blu-ray today!

Order TNG - "Redemption" Feature Blu-Ray today!

  • archer9234

    Those teens were really weird. They probably though: “let’s give them more color. Everyone looks boring on the ship.” But it really clashes with everything else. It’s like the teens are repeating the 60-70’s.

    • hypnotoad72

      I think the girls’ costumes were recycled from “Electra-Woman and Dyna-Girl”… yikes…

  • Mike Poteet

    I agree with most of your analyses, but Act 2, Sc. 42-43 is a trim that should’ve stayed in because it’s excising a much-needed moment of humanity in the midst of relentless TNG technobabble.

  • Colonel BOB Tirrel

    thanks for that Video god Love it Awesome cool you guys are doing a pretty good job well very Cool yeah keep up the good work okay Tirrell Bob Colonel

  • hypnotoad72


    It’s a shame the film segments couldn’t be found – seeing those dayglo colors in their original palette as opposed to the truncated VHS version would be interesting…

    And the nurse’s comment of “You just need something warm inside of you” really leads to a form of double entendre that’s better suited to “Family Guy” than “Star Trek”, and certainly ripe for and worthy of heckling… the thought of other teens on the ship is lofty, but in execution it’s easy to see why the whole subplot was abandoned. It just doesn’t work, and on many levels.

    • I think we can be pretty sure that the camera negative for these deleted scenes were located and scanned. It’s just that either CBS wasn’t aware of these scenes or they had already decided that deleted scenes wouldn’t be part of the special features for S3.

      • Gilbetron

        I guess I have a “warped enough mind.” 🙂 Very funny, that one. I thought I was the only person who had thought of it!

  • CaliburnCY

    Maybe it’s just because I’m used to the final cut, but I feel like Beverly’s wonderful bit at the end of the episode where she reacts to Wesley and Annette in Ten-Forward is funnier when she’s not shown onscreen to have met Annette before. “What do you know about this girl?” is the classic parental nightmare that your kids’ lives are moving on without you knowing about it. It still makes sense if Beverly has met Annette and doesn’t know her well, but it’s funnier if she hasn’t met her at all.

    It’s nice to see that Wesley has peers on the ship but I don’t think this was a great execution on that concept, and I’m content to lose all the scene with those teens. This does clarify what Wesley’s arc in the story was originally meant to be, though, and shows more clearly how Stubbs was a foil for him.

    I also think it makes Wesley look really irresponsible in Scene 41 for him not to speak up about his suspicion. I prefer the final cut where he comes to his realization while working with Geordi in the following scene. At least that way he immediately acts on his suspicion and goes to check on the nanites, whereas in the original script he says nothing on the bridge and then says nothing during a full scene of investigating with Geordi.

    As is often the case, the final edit had the right idea, I feel.

  • uzimodem

    That was really awesome! Great work!

  • Stephen Daniels

    Lol – love the text commentary! If only they had Vine in the 24th Century – that electrocution would be a barrel of laughs to watch on a six-second loop!